Why Your Business Needs Its Own Estate Plan: A California Owner’s Guide to Buy-Sell Agreements

Quick Answer: A buy-sell agreement is a binding contract among business co-owners that decides who may buy an owner’s interest, at what price, and how the purchase is funded when a triggering event happens, such as death, disability, divorce, or retirement. For California business owners, it works hand in hand with a living trust: the trust controls who receives your ownership interest, while the buy-sell agreement turns that interest into a fair, funded cash payout so your family isn’t left holding a hard-to-sell stake in a company they don’t run. A solid agreement addresses five things: the triggering events, the valuation method, the funding source (often life insurance), California community property and spousal consent, and coordination with your trust, power of attorney, and tax plan. Since the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Connelly v. United States, how the agreement is funded can also change the estate tax value of your business, so older agreements deserve a fresh review.

Introduction

Picture two friends who started a heating and air company in Sacramento 15 years ago. They split everything 50/50. They each have a living trust. Then one of them dies unexpectedly.

His trust does exactly what it says: his half of the company goes to his wife. But she has never worked in the business, and what she really needs is cash to keep the household running. His partner, meanwhile, now co-owns a company with someone who has an equal vote on every decision. Neither of them wanted this. Nobody planned for how to unwind it.

This is one of the most common gaps we see in California estate plans. A well-drafted trust tells the world who inherits your business interest. It doesn’t say who can buy it, what it’s worth, or where the money comes from. That’s the job of a buy-sell agreement, and it’s why your business needs an estate plan of its own.

For many California families, a closely held business is the single largest asset in the estate. It may be worth more than the house, the retirement accounts, and the investment portfolio combined. Yet it’s often the asset with the least planning behind it, simply because owners are busy running it.

In this guide, we’ll walk through what a buy-sell agreement is, the events it should cover, how the buyout price is set and funded, how California community property rules come into play, and how the agreement should fit with your living trust and power of attorney. We’ll also explain why a 2024 U.S. Supreme Court decision is prompting many owners to take a second look at agreements they signed years ago. If you already know you need an agreement drafted or reviewed, our experienced business planning attorneys can help.

What Is a Buy-Sell Agreement?

A buy-sell agreement (sometimes called a buyout agreement) is a contract among the owners of a closely held business. It sets the rules for what happens to an owner’s share when that owner can no longer, or should no longer, stay in the business.

It doesn’t have to be a separate document. Buy-sell terms often live inside:

  • An LLC operating agreement
  • A corporation’s shareholder agreement or bylaws
  • A partnership agreement
  • A stand-alone buy-sell agreement signed by all owners

Wherever it lives, a good agreement answers three questions in advance: who has the right (or obligation) to buy, how the price is set, and how the buyer will pay.

Why Isn’t My Living Trust Enough to Protect My Business?

A revocable living trust is an excellent tool for passing a business interest to your family without probate. But a trust only controls your side of the transaction. It can’t bind your co-owners, and it can’t create a buyer or a pot of money.

Without a buy-sell agreement, several problems can surface after an owner dies or becomes incapacitated:

  • Your family inherits an illiquid asset. A minority stake in a private company can be very hard to sell, and outside buyers rarely want one.
  • Your co-owners inherit a new partner. Your spouse or adult children may end up with voting rights in a business they’ve never worked in.
  • Nobody agrees on value. Heirs often believe the business is worth more than the surviving owners are willing to pay. Disputes can end in litigation.
  • Your heirs may get less than they expect. Under California’s LLC law, a person who receives a membership interest without being admitted as a member generally receives only the economic rights, such as distributions, not a say in management. [External link: California Corporations Code section 17705.02, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov]
  • The business itself suffers. Customers, lenders, and employees get nervous when ownership is in limbo.

Think of it this way: your trust decides who receives your share. Your buy-sell agreement decides what that share turns into.

What Events Should a Buy-Sell Agreement Cover?

Most people think of death first, but a strong agreement plans for every way an owner might leave. Common triggering events include:

  1. Death of an owner
  2. Disability or incapacity, with a clear definition (for example, unable to work for a set number of months)
  3. Divorce, when a spouse could be awarded part of the ownership interest
  4. Retirement or voluntary departure
  5. Termination of employment or loss of a professional license
  6. Bankruptcy or a creditor’s attempt to seize an owner’s interest
  7. Deadlock between owners who can no longer work together

For each event, the agreement should say whether the buyout is mandatory or optional, who buys, and how quickly the deal must close.

How Is the Buyout Price Set?

Price is where most buy-sell disputes start. California owners generally choose one of three approaches:

  • Fixed price. The owners agree on a dollar value and update it on a set schedule. It’s simple, but a price that hasn’t been updated in years can badly shortchange one side.
  • Formula. Value is calculated from a set formula, such as a multiple of earnings or book value. It updates automatically but may not reflect real market value.
  • Independent appraisal. A qualified business appraiser determines fair market value when the triggering event occurs. It’s usually the most accurate, though it costs more and takes time.

The agreement should also spell out payment terms: a lump sum, installments over several years, interest on any unpaid balance, and security for the seller if the buyer pays over time.

One caution for larger estates: the price in your agreement doesn’t automatically control the value the IRS uses for estate tax. Federal tax rules require the agreement to meet specific tests before its price will be respected. If your estate could be taxable, your valuation clause should be drafted with those rules in mind.

How Do You Pay for a Buyout?

A buyout is only as good as the money behind it. An agreement that obligates your partner to pay $1.5 million is of little use if your partner doesn’t have $1.5 million.

Life Insurance

Life insurance is the most common funding source for death buyouts because it pays out exactly when the money is needed. There are two main ways to structure it:

  • Cross-purchase agreement. Each owner buys a policy on the other owners. When one dies, the survivors collect the proceeds and buy the deceased owner’s share directly.
  • Entity redemption (stock redemption) agreement. The business owns a policy on each owner. When an owner dies, the company collects the proceeds and buys back that owner’s share.

Cross-purchase plans get unwieldy as the number of owners grows, since each owner needs a policy on every other owner. Some businesses use a trusteed cross-purchase arrangement or a separate insurance LLC to hold the policies.

What Did the Connelly Decision Change?

In June 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Connelly v. United States, a case involving two brothers who owned a building supply company with a company-funded redemption agreement. The Court held that life insurance proceeds the company received on a deceased owner’s life count toward the company’s value for federal estate tax purposes, and that the company’s duty to use those proceeds to buy back the shares does not offset that value.

In plain terms, a company-owned policy can increase the taxable value of the deceased owner’s share. In the Connelly case, the result was a substantially larger estate tax bill.

The ruling matters most for owners whose estates may exceed the federal exemption, which is $15 million per person in 2026 under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. California has no state estate tax. If your agreement uses company-owned insurance and your estate is near or above the federal threshold, it’s worth asking whether a cross-purchase structure or another approach makes more sense.

Other Funding Options

  • Disability buyout insurance to fund a buyout if an owner becomes permanently disabled
  • Installment payments from the buyer or the business over time
  • A sinking fund the business builds up for future buyouts
  • Bank financing, which may be harder to obtain right after an owner’s death

How Does California Community Property Affect My Business Agreement?

In California, property acquired during marriage is generally presumed to be community property. That often includes a business interest, even if only one spouse’s name appears on the paperwork. Your spouse may own a one-half community interest in your share of the company.

That creates two risks for a buy-sell agreement:

  • At death, your surviving spouse already owns their half of the community interest. Your trust only controls your half. The buy-sell agreement needs to reach both halves.
  • At divorce, a family court may award part of the business interest to the non-owner spouse.

The standard solution is a spousal consent. Each owner’s spouse signs a short document agreeing that any community interest they hold is bound by the buy-sell terms. Without one, key provisions may not be enforceable against the spouse. California law also limits a spouse’s ability to give away or dispose of community personal property for less than fair value without the other spouse’s written consent. [External link: California Family Code section 1100, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov]

If an owner marries after the agreement is signed, getting the new spouse’s consent should be on the to-do list.

How Does a Buy-Sell Agreement Fit With My Trust and Estate Plan?

Your business plan and your personal estate plan should be built to work together. Here’s where they connect.

Holding Your Business Interest in Your Trust

Transferring your shares or LLC interest into your revocable trust can keep that interest out of probate. Before you do, check your operating or shareholder agreement. Many restrict transfers and require consent, though most allow transfers to an owner’s own revocable trust. The buy-sell agreement should also recognize your successor trustee as someone who can sign the buyout documents. 

Planning for Incapacity

If you become incapacitated, someone needs authority to vote your shares, sign checks, and negotiate a disability buyout. A durable power of attorney that specifically covers business interests, along with clear successor trustee provisions, can keep the company running and help your family avoid a court conservatorship.

S Corporation Ownership Rules

If your company is an S corporation, only certain kinds of trusts can hold the shares without jeopardizing the tax election. A revocable trust is generally fine during your lifetime. After your death, the trust typically has a limited window to qualify under special trust rules or transfer the shares. Your trust should be drafted with those requirements in mind.

Business Real Estate

If your company owns real property, a change in who controls the company can trigger a property tax reassessment in California, even when no deed changes hands. A buyout that shifts majority control is a common example. Plan the buyout with your attorney and CPA so a property tax increase doesn’t come as a surprise. 

Directing the Buyout Proceeds

Once your share becomes cash, your trust decides where that cash goes. Consider whether the proceeds should go outright to your spouse, be held in trust for children, or be equalized among a child who works in the business and children who don’t.

When Should You Review Your Buy-Sell Agreement?

Treat your buy-sell agreement like any other part of your estate plan. Review it:

  • At least once a year, especially if it uses a fixed price
  • When an owner marries, divorces, or has a child
  • When a new owner joins or an existing owner leaves
  • When the business value changes significantly
  • When life insurance policies are purchased, changed, or lapse
  • When tax laws change, as they did with the 2024 Connelly decision and the 2026 estate tax exemption

Protect the Business You Built

You’ve spent years building your company. A buy-sell agreement makes sure that value reaches your family as fair, timely cash, and that the business you built can keep going without you. Paired with a well-drafted living trust, it gives your family, your co-owners, and your employees a clear plan instead of a negotiation at the worst possible moment.

Our experienced estate planning attorneys help California business owners put buy-sell agreements in place and make sure their trust, power of attorney, and business agreements work together. We also coordinate with your CPA and financial advisor so every piece of the plan fits.

Call us at 916-488-9788 or contact us online to schedule a no-cost consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Do I need a buy-sell agreement if I co-own my business with a family member?

A: Yes, often even more so. Family co-owners may assume things will “work out,” but a death or divorce can put in-laws or the next generation in a position nobody intended. A written agreement protects relationships as well as the business.

Q: Is a buy-sell agreement the same as an LLC operating agreement?

A: Not necessarily. Many operating agreements include buy-sell terms, but some only restrict transfers without setting a price or a funding plan. Review yours to see whether it actually answers who buys, at what price, and with what money.

Q: What happens to my business interest if I die without a buy-sell agreement in California?

A: Your interest passes under your trust, your will, or California’s intestacy laws. Your heirs may inherit an interest they can’t easily sell, and your co-owners have no obligation to buy it at a fair price. If the interest isn’t held in a trust, it may also have to go through probate.

Q: Does a buy-sell agreement avoid probate?

A: Not by itself. A buy-sell agreement is a contract about who buys your interest. Holding the interest in a properly funded revocable trust is what typically keeps it out of probate. The two work best together.

Q: How often should we update the buyout price?

A: If your agreement uses a fixed price, update it at least once a year. Many agreements say that if the price hasn’t been updated within a set period, an appraisal will be used instead. That backup provision can prevent a stale number from controlling the buyout.

Download our Free “Estate Planning Essentials” eBook

Taking the time to create a comprehensive estate plan is critical for everyone. We have helped many clients develop personalized estate plans. Whether you already have an estate plan that you would like to update or you would like to create your first estate plan, we can help. Download our free "Estate Planning Essentials" eBook to get started.